The Tillie Pierce House Inn

We stayed in the Hettie suite. While this could have been a good experience we left extremely disappointed. It's clear the owners have no idea what details are important. First, be advised there is no staff onsite overnight, this is basically a boarding house. The listing said "triple room ensuite" it wasn't. Just a bedroom and small bath with an extremely uncomfortable bed. No A/C control in the room and no fan, so we roasted over night. No trash can in the room. No closet or wardrobe (which was expected) but not even a single hanger for a shirt. Common areas had TVs which could be heard very clearly right through the walls at all hours. On top of that, the website stated free breakfast and gluten free options. I noted in the reservation that we needed GF and I let the staff know upon check-in as well. But the only GF option was some barely cooked, frozen "home fries". Overall extremely disappointed especially considering the price.

This is our first stay at a BnB in which the innkeeper was not the owner. The inn has the potential to be a remarkable experience, but misses the mark. The good: It is centrally located in Gettysburg with only a short walk to the center of the town. Our room was a suite of 4 small rooms (breakfast, sitting, bath, bed. Off-street parking behind the inn was convenient and easily accessible. The innkeeper, Gail, was friendly and informative, knowing a lot about the history of Tillie Pierce. The other: Our suite could have used a thorough vacuuming. The bedroom was cold and the rear entrance should have a door sweep to keep the draft out. Our departure was not extremely early, but there were no breakfast items available, only snacks from the prior day. While the price we paid would be reasonable for the suite, we thought it was overpriced based on the conditions we experienced.

I've always driven past the Inn and wanted to stay there. I was here for two days,and enjoyed every moment. I had the first floor room and there were no other guests at the inn, so it was wonderful. The hosts Gail and Bob were very kind. Breakfast was scrambled eggs and bacon one morning and French toast , strawberries and bacon the second morning. If you're a light sleeper, you may want to bring ear plugs to tone down the traffic noise from Baltimore street....I always have a set with me for this reason. Thank you for a wonderful stay!!

So needs a good deep clean. The house is a lovely old building and whilst the hosts were very kind the place needs a deep clean. The dust on lights, mirrors etc is hard to miss. Someone else’s hair on the supposedly clean towels . The lighting needs updating and the bAck garden could do with some work. Plus side is it’s within walking distance from the centre of town and near to eating places. I wish I could have written a better review but this place needs help !

This quaint bed-and-breakfast is ideally situated in historic, downtown Gettysburg, near many sites and events. It is also the perfect location if you are visiting Gettysburg College. If you are vegan, vegetarian or need gluten-free food, this is the perfect place! We are vegetarian, and the host made us the most phenomenal breakfast with plant-based meat and eggs. Cozy accommodations with a private en suite bathroom. Has all the charm of a historic BnB. A must visit if you’re in Gettysburg.