Haar with Rooms 5 Stars

Our stay at the Haar Hotel was amazing. David and the rest of the staff were beyond accommodating and always super kind. The location of the hotel is hard to beat and the breakfast was always fresh and delicious. We would stay there again in a heartbeat and would highly recommend to all.

Absolutely stunning stay at Haar over Hogmanay! We were lucky enough to have a room with a view overlooking the West Sands fireworks - the perfect way to ring in the New Year. The room was beautifully decorated with thoughtful touches throughout, from the homemade shortbread on arrival to the Nespresso machine and robes. Breakfast the next morning was next level - freshly made, two generous courses, and the eggs Benedict was spot on. Every member of staff we met was warm, friendly, and genuinely attentive. Couldn’t fault a thing. 100% returning - a real gem in St Andrews.

I'll start on a positive; my wife and I had the dinner tasting menu, which was absolutely excellent. In addition, we ordered the scallop with king oyster mushrooms, which was also excellent. The 'Black Friday' deal we had bought also included an overnight stay in a 'cosy double'. We've stayed in many hotels where the description was 'cosy double', but this took the term to a different level, with barely any room to move around and almost zero storage/hanging space. That said, the bathroom was lovely and almost spacious by comparison. We arrived at The Haar to be greeted by a very pleasant young woman who carried out the check-in formalities and showed us up to our room. She explained that there was an issue with the lock but showed us how it operated, etc. There was no issue locking when we left a short time later,but when we tried to do the same before going down for dinner, we couldn't lock the door. I reported this to one of the front of house staff, but he experienced a similar problem and stated he would ask his manager to look at it if we'd like to take a seat downstairs. A few minutes later, the manager appeared, declaring that the door was now locked and implied incompetence on our part. I reminded him that his colleague also experienced the same issue. Then the manager (still don't know his name) asked to see our voucher. We told him we didn't have a voucher, but we have emails confirming room and table bookings. However, he insisted we needed to produce the 16 digit reference or risk being charged again, despite the fact that we'd shown him our cr card payment on the banking app. To cut to the chase, this chap was borderline rude and despite clear proof of purchase and confirmation of bookings, failed to deal with a situation that was all of his and The Haar's administration system's doing, not ours. Needless to say, we won't be returning.

Very enjoyable stay. Comfortable bed so slept well. Coffee machine in room and homemade shortbread was a lovely touch. Dinner and breakfast amazing as were the staff. I will definitely return and have already recommended to friends. Great central location and close to beach area and shops. A great foodie experience all round.

This is a gastronomical restaurant with hotel rooms attached. So it’s a not obvious that it’s a hotel - but it is a gem . The rooms were small(ish) but we had a view to the sea, and they’re beautifully appointed. The young staff are helpful and charming. Breakfast, included in room fee, is outta this world. We were traveling w teens so didn’t take advantage of the tasting menu dinner. All in all, wonderful.

Pros: clean, reasonable bathroom, good breakfast, good location, nice receptionist. Cons: tiny tiny bedroom, poorly decorated, hot, tv doesn’t work, no wardrobe, no chair, no space for luggage, no desk, no lift, no parking, common parts clearly taken from a failing vegetarian restaurant, expensive, insecure locks, brown toilet roll. Overall, a bit pooey.